Vintage Halloween Games

Popular with Partygoers and now Collectors

© Susan Cramer

fortune wheel by beistle 1928, m ledenbach

Halloween score pads and games are a popular segment of vintage Halloween collectibles.

Tally Cards

In the early part of the century, Halloween was celebrated at parties, typically by adults. They would gather at each others’ homes, and play social games like Bridge and Mahjong. Consequently, there is a wide variety of collectibles in the form of tally pads. These pads were used for keeping score and were often elaborately decorated. Many were cut-outs in complicated shapes complete with cord. While many cards were flat or folded, some were much more complicated. Mechanical tally cards were like modern day pop-ups, where the scene changed. Denison made a popular card in 1929-30 that portrayed a witch’s head in a fiery cauldron. When the tab was pulled, the witch disappeared into the brew. Beistle made a three dimensional set with the characters sporting honeycombed crepe paper tutus. Tally cards were mostly made by American manufacturers, and range in price from $25 to $90.

Fortune Telling

Since Halloween in America has always been a holiday whose purpose is pure fun, Halloween games played a major part in any party. These were games of skill, chance, stunts and fortunes. The earliest games were made to be played by adults, which is why the Mystery Witch Answer Game asks questions such as “Will I own a home?” and “Will I become bald?” The fortune wheel featured flaps that folded out and told fortunes. The Crystal Fortunes game by Beistle (1942) featured a numbered spinner. The player’s fortune was read from a poster with a dozen fortunes that corresponded to that number, different fortunes for boys and for girls. Also by Beistle, the Halloween Stunt Quiz (1940’s) asked questions that today could culminate in lawsuits like “Do I like old people?” and “Am I too fat?”

Stunt Games

Stunt games required that the participants complete such tasks as spinning blindfolded, pushing an apple across the floor using only the nose, whistling Yankee Doodle while wearing a sauce pan, or yodeling. The names of the games were as clever as the challenges. One could play Zingo Halloween Fortune & Stunt; I’m a Dumbskull Stunt Game, Owl Tell Your Fortune and Spin-O-Rama.

Skill Games

Games of skill were also popular. Partygoers could toss rings in the shape of donuts at witches, Jack-O-Lanterns, and the tails of growling black cats. The Hitchy Witch game (Beistle 1940’s) had a ring on a string that players could hook on the witch’s nose, chin or hat for a variety of scores. Other skills included tongue twisters, drawing and target shooting. As with other Halloween ephemera, the games were meant to be used and discarded. Often the pieces were printed on a single sheet and had to be punched out before use, so sometimes finding a complete game is as easy as pushing an apple with your nose.

SOURCE: Vintage Halloween Collectibles An Identification and Price Guide 2nd Edition by Mark B. Ledenbach 2007 Krause Publications Photos with permission of Author


The copyright of the article Vintage Halloween Games in Antiques & Collectibles is owned by Susan Cramer. Permission to republish Vintage Halloween Games must be granted by the author in writing.


fortune wheel by beistle 1928, m ledenbach
I'm a dumbskull game beistle 1930, m ledenbach
spin-0-rama beistle 1960's, m ledenbach
hitchy witch beistle 1940's, m ledenbach
fortune wheel beistle 1931, m ledenbach


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo